Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Macmillan runs a graduate recruitment scheme and has done for more than thirty years. We are the only publisher in Britain (and maybe in the world) to have consistently and systematically tried to bring into the industry high-calibre people without a specific job vacancy. It has been a great success within Macmillan (five of our current crop of managing directors are from the scheme and 25 are not - it is not the sole qualification) and within the industry (two of the top six British publishers are run by ex-Macmillan graduate recruits and they occupy many other top slots).

I have just interviewed six of this year's applicants and I'm confident that the traditon of excellence will continue. The industry continues to be attractive for the best and the brightest but we need to maintain that by being and being seen to be innovative and relevant. Sometimes that is a bit of a challenge.

The new head of the HMV Group (which owns Waterstone's), Simon Fox, has had to open his tenure with a profits warning and announcement of a significant number of store closures as described here. I'm sure that there are cost savings to be made in the book supply chain and we are going to work with the new team to find and implement them. Right now a book is handled around twenty times between printer and purchaser and every handling costs money and introduces the chance of error. While we're doing that (which inevitably involves introspection) it's vital that Waterstone's (along with all other retailers) don't forget to look outwards at their customer base and its expectations. I do hope 'more emphasis on novels, cookery and children's books and less on "academic and humanities" areas' doesn't mean what I think it means - further homogenisation of the bookshop experience. Mind you, if it does, then independent booksellers should be able to benefit from filling the gap.

3/14/2007 9:31:02 AM (GMT Standard Time, UTC+00:00)
Too much supply chain handling : sell *all* books firm sale - even to Amazon and Tesco, let alone Waterstone and W H Smith.

One day perhaps, there will be more than a mere handful of publishers who are prepared to grant better terms to booksellers who take *all* stock firm sale.

If bookchains were prepared to take their stock firm sale and have a proper January sale clearout then perhaps they might see a busier high street.

Adventurous independent bookshops are flourishing at the moment, thanks in no small part to the bland selection available within the bookchains and supermarkets.
3/14/2007 11:16:30 AM (GMT Standard Time, UTC+00:00)
I know I am a bit like an old LP stuck in a groove but when you read those comments from the management of HMV and Waterstone's, it makes me think how important it is that we get the public library service up and running again.

I know that independent book sellers will take "humanities and academic" works seriously, but both the publishing industry and the public need to be buffered against the whim of a small number or commercial operators and their strategies. That, in the long run, has always been the reason why we needed a good public library service. We have been spoiled for a few years by national booksellers who thought arts and humanities are important, but we can't depend on that situation always existing. Remember it is not so long ago in the 70's that WHSmith dominated book-selling with nearly a quarter of book sales. Public libraries were very important then.
3/14/2007 1:31:37 PM (GMT Standard Time, UTC+00:00)
According to the business article in the Guardian, Waterstone intend to close their last six remaining outlets in University campuses : this is surely clear evidence that the new Waterstone management have little interest in the academic market, although I read a comment somewhere, which was attributed to Simon Cox, saying that customers could purchase such items on line !!!!

If I was a younger man I would jump at the prospect of running a few such campus outlets, with all the challenges, and hope that somebody from the independent booktrade will take up the void left by Waterstone.